THE PURE EDIT

The State of the Theatre

A discerning look at the stage, its players, and the art of performance, as it should be.

The Promise of the Theatre

In pursuit of an evening worth remembering.
Audience awaiting the performance in a red and gold theatre.

The lights go down. The orchestra draws its breath. And for the next few hours, the world outside ceases to exist.

This is the promise of the theatre, and those who have felt it never forget it. We remember the first time we saw The Phantom of the Opera, and it was not spectacle alone that undid us. It was the caliber of the performers, voices and performances so astonishing that the machinery of the production vanished and only the story remained. We remember, too, an evening at The Sound of Music, which became something more durable than an outing. It became a memory. That is what the theatre does. From the moment the lights fall until they rise again, we are lost inside that shining rectangle, and emerge changed.

A great deal is asked to achieve it. The singing must be on point, the acting true, the orchestra rich. The house itself should be a pleasure: gilded or black-box intimate, but clean, beautiful, and comfortable, because nothing kills enchantment faster than an aching back or a sticky floor. And the audience should arrive as if for an occasion, dressed for it, with someone worth sharing it with, even if that someone is oneself.

None of this depends on size. A jewel box of a theatre can rival the grandest opera house, and two actors on a spare stage can hold an audience spellbound.

This column exists to champion the theatre at its best, and to make the case, one installment at a time, for a golden age worth returning to. What that looks like, we will reveal in time: what to cherish, what to restore, and what to leave behind. For now, this much we will say: a play people can love again, a beautiful night out, a few hours spent entirely inside a different story, and a house full of people who do not want it to end.

So go, but go only when a production promises to be excellent. Dress for it. Bring someone you love. Support greatness wherever you find it, and ask nothing less of those who take your money.

Good theatre should feel like Christmas, even when it breaks your heart. That is the promise, and it is one we will keep asking the theatre to make good on.

The Cultural Edit

Selections are independently chosen by our editors. We may earn a commission through shopping links.

Season Subscription

The Old Globe

Season Subscription

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

Live theater is one of the cultural experiences that cannot be replicated by a screen. A season subscription also encourages the best kind of cultural habit: seeing work you might not have chosen from a single title or review.

VIEW DETAILS

The Old Globe

Season Subscription

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

Live theater is one of the cultural experiences that cannot be replicated by a screen. A season subscription also encourages the best kind of cultural habit: seeing work you might not have chosen from a single title or review.

The Red Shoes, 4K UHD + Blu-ray

The Criterion Collection

The Red Shoes, 4K UHD + Blu-ray

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

One of cinema’s great arguments for beauty, obsession and art as an all-consuming vocation. The restoration and supplements make the Criterion edition worth owning even in a streaming world.

VIEW DETAILS

The Criterion Collection

The Red Shoes, 4K UHD + Blu-ray

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

One of cinema’s great arguments for beauty, obsession and art as an all-consuming vocation. The restoration and supplements make the Criterion edition worth owning even in a streaming world.

Print + Digital Subscription

The New York Review of Books

Print + Digital Subscription

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

A subscription for people who still want criticism to be long enough to change their minds. The Review combines books, politics, history, science and the arts while giving subscribers access to an extraordinary archive reaching back to 1963.

VIEW DETAILS

The New York Review of Books

Print + Digital Subscription

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

A subscription for people who still want criticism to be long enough to change their minds. The Review combines books, politics, history, science and the arts while giving subscribers access to an extraordinary archive reaching back to 1963.

The New York Review of Books

Print + Digital Subscription

$129.95 / year

The New York Review of Books
Annual Membership

MUBI

Annual Membership

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

A useful counterpoint to Criterion: more contemporary international cinema, festival discoveries and a deliberately smaller curated selection instead of another enormous streaming library. Monthly membership is also available at $14.99.

VIEW DETAILS

MUBI

Annual Membership

WHY IT MADE THE EDIT

A useful counterpoint to Criterion: more contemporary international cinema, festival discoveries and a deliberately smaller curated selection instead of another enormous streaming library. Monthly membership is also available at $14.99.

MUBI

Annual Membership

$119.88 / year

MUBI

The State of the Theatre

Red velvet theatre curtains part over a softly lit stage.

The First Duty of the Theatre

The story is master.